The Causal Relationship between Angina Pectoris and Gout Based on Two Sample Mendelian Randomization

Purpose Two-sample Mendelian randomization (MR) was conducted to assess the causal relationship between angina pectoris and gout. Material and Methods. Based on genome-wide association studies, single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that were closely associated with gout were selected from the UK Biobank–Neale Lab (ukb-a-107) as genetic instrumental variables. Considering that gout is characterized by elevated blood uric acid levels, SNPs related to blood uric acid levels were screened from BioBank Japan (bbj-a-57) as auxiliary gene instrumental variables. SNPs closely associated with angina pectoris onset were screened from the FINN dataset (finn-b-I9_ANGINA) as outcome variables. Two-sample MR was conducted, with inverse variance weighting (IVW) of the random effects model as the primary result, along with the weighted median method (WME) and the MR-Egger regression method. To further confirm the causal relationship between angina and gout incidence, a meta-analysis was conducted on the IVW results of the ukb-a-107 and bbj-a-57. Results The odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals of the IVW, WME, and MR-Egger results of ukb-a-107 were (OR = 33.72; 95% CI: 2.07∼550.38), (OR = 57.94; 95% CI: 2.75∼1219.82), and (OR = 96.38; 95% CI: 0.6∼15556.93), respectively. The P values of IVW and WME were 0.014 and 0.014 (both <0.05), respectively, indicating that the development of angina pectoris was significantly associated with the incidence of gout. The odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals of the IVW, WME, and MR-Egger about bbj-a-57 were (OR = 1.20; 95% CI: 1.07∼1.34), (OR = 1.19; 95% CI: 1.02∼1.38), and (OR = 1.30; 95% CI; 1.06∼1.60), respectively. The P values of IVW, WME and MR-Egger were 0.001, 0.027 and 0.017 (all <0.05), respectively, indicating a significant correlation between angina and blood uric acid levels. Scatter plots of ukb-a-107 and bbj-a-57 showed that the causal association estimates of the IVW, MR-Egger, and weighted median methods were similar and that the MR results were accurate. Funnel plots and the MR-Egger intercept of ukb-a-107 and bbj-a-57 showed the absence of horizontal pleiotropy. The leave-out sensitivity analysis results of ukb-a-107 and bbj-a-57 are stable. The meta-analysis of IVW results for ukb-a-107 and bbj-a-57 showed (OR = 1.20; 95% CI: 1.07–1.34, P=0.02), confirming that gout characterized by high blood uric acid levels significantly increases the risk of angina attacks. Conclusions This MR study found a clear causal relationship between angina pectoris and gout, which increases the risk of angina pectoris.


Introduction
Gout is a metabolic disease that results from the deposition of urate crystals in joints and cartilage tissues, thereby triggering infammation and pain, and is associated with purine metabolism disorders and/or uric acid excretion reduction, which results in excessively high blood uric acid concentrations (>0.48 mmol/L) [1].Te clinical manifestations of gout include acute exacerbations of arthritis, gouty tophus formation, and chronic gouty arthritis with tophi, and severe cases can lead to joint disability and renal insufciency.Gout is often accompanied by other metabolic syndrome-related manifestations, such as cardiovascular disease [2][3][4], dyslipidaemia, and type 2 diabetes mellitus.According to pathological anatomy and the observed pathophysiological changes, angina pectoris has a clinical phenotype of coronary heart disease, which is related to the atherosclerosis of coronary arteries causing luminal narrowing or occlusion.Moreover, an increase in myocardial load results in temporary ischaemia and myocardial hypoxia, which leads to the patient developing clinical manifestations such as chest tightness, chest pain, and shortness of breath [5,6].
Te incidence of gout and angina pectoris is currently rising year over year [7,8].Te prevalence of gout has increased worldwide in recent decades, with the global statistical prevalence of gout ranging from 0.1% to 10.0% [9].Over the past decade, deaths due to cardiovascular disease have increased globally by 12.5%, accounting for approximately one-third of the overall deaths worldwide [10].Gout is strongly associated with blood uric acid, and elevated blood uric acid levels form an important pathological basis for gout pathogenesis.Te association between serum uric acid levels and cardiovascular risk has been studied for decades, and some clinical studies have shown that serum uric acid is a predictor of cardiovascular disease prognosis and that elevated serum uric acid levels may be associated with increased risks of cardiovascular disease and death [11].A case-control study published in JAMA by the Edoardo Cipolletta team at the University of Nottingham showed that gout is an independent risk factor for cardiovascular disease 【2】 -the incidence of gout was found to be associated with an increased incidence of short-term cardiovascular events, and patients who experienced cardiovascular events had a signifcantly increased incidence of gout during the frst 60 days and the frst 61-120 days compared with those who did not experience cardiovascular events (0-60 days, OR � 1.93; 61-120 days, OR � 1.57).Tese results suggest that the incidence of gout is associated with transient increases in the incidence of cardiovascular events, and the prevention and immediate treatment of patients with gout with cardiovascular events is particularly important.However, the relationship between angina pectoris and the incidence of gout lacks detailed evidence and warrants support from high-quality clinical research, and the relationship between angina pectoris and the incidence of gout needs to be elucidated as soon as possible.
Clinical observational studies are susceptible to the risk of deviations due to statistical or environmental factors and do not substantiate the association between angina pectoris and gout fares.To further investigate the causal relationship between angina pectoris and gout, the strength of the association, and the direction of the causal relationship, a Mendelian randomization (MR) method proposed by Professor Katan [12] in 1986 has been used in this study to consider genetic variants as tool variables for testing the causal relationship between exposure factors and outcome factors.Te MR method is commonly used in data analysis to assess aetiological inferences in epidemiological studies.According to Mendel's second law, this genetic variation cannot be altered by other factors; this property efectively reduces the impact of confounding factors and reverse causality and compensates for the shortcomings of clinical observational studies.Te publication of a large number of pooled data related to exposure to and genetic variation between diseases has made it feasible to estimate the causeand-efect relationships between the investigated diseases in large samples of MR data [13].Te results of MR analysis can provide a reference for clinical practice, suggesting that clinicians need to consider the correlation between the incidence of angina pectoris and gout attacks in patients, do a good job of preventing these diseases in advance, and optimise patient treatment and management processes.

Overall Study Design.
A two-sample MR method was used to analyse the causal relationship between gout and angina pectoris, with gout as the exposure factor and angina pectoris as the outcome variable.Considering that gout is characterized by an increase in blood uric acid levels, this study chose blood uric acid levels as an auxiliary exposure factor.Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were designated as instrumental variables (IVs).Using SNPs as a modelling approach, similar to that used in randomised controlled trials, can help identify causal associations between exposure traits, such as gout, and outcome traits, especially angina.Specifcally, based on publicly available human genome information from genome-wide association studies (GWAS), information on SNPs with statistically signifcant value related to gout and blood uric acid levels was screened as a genetic instrumental variable; information on angina was subsequently obtained through another survey derived from the Finnish database (FinnGen R9), which identifed the presence of relevant SNPs; fnally, using the screened SNPs, multiple MR methods were used to infer the association between gout and risk of angina (Figure 1).

Basic Assumptions for Two-Sample MR.
Te two-sample MR method used in this study used the following three key assumptions [16]: (1) Hypothesis I: Genetic variants are signifcantly associated with exposure; i.e., a signifcant association exists between instrumental variables and gout.
2 Pain Research and Management (2) Hypothesis II: Genetic variation is not associated with any confounder associated with exposureoutcome; i.e., instrumental variables are not associated with all confounders associated with gout and angina.(3) Assumption III: Genetic variation afects outcomes only through association with the exposure factor; instrumental variables afect outcomes only through association with gout.

SNP Screening of Instrumental
Variables.R software was used to obtain data from websites and perform tool variable SNP screening operations.SNPs were selected based on comprehensive criteria [17][18][19].First, SNPs exhibiting a robust association with gout at a genome-wide signifcance threshold of 5 × 10e−8 were included.Second, SNPs were chosen to be independent of each other, ensuring that the impact of linkage disequilibrium (LD) on the results was minimised.Specifcally, a stringent criterion of r 2 � 0.01, with a window size of 10000 kb, was applied to avoid bias induced by LD.Moreover, the correlation between the instrumental variables (IVs) and exposure factors was assessed using the F-statistic of the SNPs.Generally, IVs with an Fstatistic >10 are considered unbiased indicators.[20,21].Tis method provides the most accurate estimates, and the regression does not require consideration of the intercept term, using the inverse of the variance of each IV as weights to perform the ft.Te weighted average of the IV efect values was considered the fnal result, similar to the MR maximum likelihood estimation with the lowest variance of the efect estimates.If an SNP did not conform to the IV hypothesis, a random defect IVW was used to produce a bias that measures each rate against its standard error when considering possible heterogeneity.On the premise that all IVs were valid and no pleiotropy existed, the 20 SNPs in this study were measured one by one using the ratio method as well as the weighted regression method to obtain the overall estimate.

Weighted Median Method.
To satisfy the premise of efective instrumental variables, the WME method requires an efective IV of >50%.After sorting the included SNPs according to their weights, the median is considered the result.Te causal estimates obtained by this method provide good agreement [22].

MR-Egger Regression Method.
If the genetic tool does not depend on the pleiotropic efect, an estimate of the efect can be obtained through MR-Egger regression.Te MR-Egger regression method [23][24][25] uses the reciprocal of outcome variance as the weight for ftting; it also adds an  Pain Research and Management intercept term to evaluate the pleiotropic efect simultaneously with regression.If the MR-Egger intercept is not signifcantly diferent from zero, the directional multiplication efect cannot be proved.

Sensitivity Analysis.
Te MR-Egger method, Cochran's Q test, and leave-one-out test were used to evaluate the sensitivity of the results.Additionally, an investigation of published GWAS data revealed no signifcant associations between the SNPs associated with gout and any other phenotypes, except for gout itself, indicating that the assumptions underlying the third MR analysis were upheld without violation.In terms of MR analysis, the second hypothesis assumes that SNPs exert their infuence only by modifying interest exposures, without involving other confounding pathways.To evaluate the multidirectional nature of the direction of the SNPs, the intercept and corresponding P values were obtained using the MR-Egger regression method.When the intercept was almost zero, the result obtained was close to the IVW.Generally, if there is a large gap between the intercept term and 0, horizontal pleiotropy may exist between IVs [26].Te diferences among IVs were examined using Cochran's Q test.Te greater the diferences, the stronger the heterogeneity.Funnel plots can efectively illustrate the directional horizontal pleiotropy of IVs by assigning a single Wald ratio for each SNP.Te leave-one-out method eliminates SNPs one by one and calculates the efect generated by the combination of other units to clarify the efect of a single SNP on the outcome and evaluates the degree and stability of the impact.Te results are expressed as odds ratio (OR) and 95% confdence intervals (95% CI).P < 0.05 was considered statistically signifcant [27].

Meta-Analysis.
To comprehensively evaluate the relationship between gout and angina, we considered using blood uric acid levels as an auxiliary exposure tool.We used the "Meta" software package to perform meta-analysis on the IVW results of ukb-a-107 (gout) and bbj-a-57 (blood uric acid levels).Perform heterogeneity test analysis on the obtained results, and when I 2 ≤ 50%, it indicates no signifcant heterogeneity; when I 2 > 50%, it indicates signifcant heterogeneity, and heterogeneity source analysis should be conducted; and P < 0.05 is the standard for statistically signifcant diferences.

Status of IVs Related to Gout and Blood Uric Acid Levels.
Following the exclusion of LD, a total of 17 IVs associated with gout were acquired, and the SNPs were characterized according to the information provided (Table 2).Similarly, we obtained 32 instrumental variables related to blood uric acid levels (    Terefore, the results obtained from the 17 SNPs as IVs were relatively stable and not subject to bias by potential factors. Similarly, the Cochran Q-test for the relationship between blood uric acid levels and angina showed that the Q-values and Qp of IVW and MR-Egger regression were 34.6053 (0.2997) and 33.5863 (0.2977), respectively.P values greater than 0.05 indicate that there is no heterogeneity in SNPs.Te distribution of causal efects shown in the funnel plot for each SNP is basically symmetrical (Figure 4(b)).Terefore, the results obtained by using 32 SNPs as instrumental variables are relatively stable and not subject to bias caused by potential factors.

"Leave-One-Out" Rejection Tests.
In the MR analysis of the relationship between gout and angina pectoris, sensitivity analysis was performed using the leave-one-out method.After removing one SNP at a time, the remaining 16 SNPs were used as genetic IVs and subsequently analysed using IVW efect analysis to determine whether individual SNPs would afect the analysis results.After removing individual SNPs sequentially, the IVW efect values of the remaining SNPs did not fuctuate considerably, and all of them were close to the position of the red dots in the fgure, with all P > 0.05, indicating that there was no SNP with strong infuence on the results in the IVs.Moreover, there were no SNPs in the variables that had a strong efect on the results, indicating that the results obtained by the previous IVW method were stable and reliable (Figure 5(a)).Similarly, in the MR analysis of the relationship between blood uric acid levels and angina pectoris, the leave-one-out method showed that after sequentially removing individual SNPs, the IVW efect values of the remaining 31 SNPs did not show signifcant fuctuations, all close to the red dots in the fgure, and the P value results were all greater than 0.05, indicating that the results obtained by the IVW method were stable and reliable (Figure 5(b)).

Meta-Analysis.
Gout is a crystal associated joint disease caused by the deposition of monosodium urate, directly related to hyperuricemia caused by purine metabolism disorders and/or decreased uric acid excretion.In order to comprehensively evaluate the relationship between gout and angina, while using gout as the primary exposure tool, we considered using blood uric acid levels as an auxiliary exposure tool.In this study, we conducted a meta-analysis on the IVW results of ukb-a-107 (gout) and bbj-a-57 (blood uric acid levels) (OR � 1.20; 95% CI: 1.07-1.34,P � 0.02), indicating that gout characterized by high blood uric acid levels signifcantly increases the risk of angina (Figure 6).Heterogeneity testing showed signifcant heterogeneity among the studies (P � 0.02 < 0.05, I 2 � 82%).Te bbj-a-57 refects blood uric acid levels; From the perspective of efect size, the bbj-a-57 efect is relatively small; Te overall sample size of bbj-a-57 is relatively small, and the sample comes from East Asia, which together leads to the existence of heterogeneity.However, in this study, it can be preliminarily determined that both gout and blood uric acid levels are risk factors for angina, which further confrms that gout is a risk factor for angina and high blood uric acid levels play a mediating role between the two.

Discussion
Te IVW, WME, and MR-Egger regression methods were used to infer the causal relationship between angina pectoris and the onset of gout using two-sample MR methods for the included SNPs and to test the accuracy and stability of the obtained results.Moreover, the IVW analysis of variance (AVW), WME, and MR-Egger regression methods were used for the inclusion of the included SNPs, and the accuracy and stability of the results were examined.Te IVW method [OR � 33.72 (95% CI: 2.07-550.38,P � 0.0135 < 0.05)].Te WME method (OR � 57.94 (95% CI � 2.71-1236.38,P � 0.0093)) results showed that people sufering from gout had an increased risk of the prevalence of an angina attack.Moreover, the scatter plot showed that the causal association estimates of the IVW, MR-Egger, and WME methods were similar and that the IVW results prevailed, indicating that the MR results were accurate.Horizontal pleiotropy was assessed using the MR-Egger regression method, which indicated that there was no horizontal pleiotropy (egger intercept � −0.004466, P � 0.631).IVW (P � 0.066) and MR-Egger regression (P � 0.052), as demonstrated by the Cochran Q-test, suggested the absence of heterogeneity.Te results of the leave-one-out sensitivity analysis showed that after eliminating each SNP turn by turn, the IVW analysis results of the remaining SNPs were similar to those of the inclusion of all SNPs; moreover, no strongly infuential SNP sites were found, i.e., the SNPs would not have a nonspecifc efect on the results.Trough the funnel plot, we observed that the scatter of causal association efects was symmetrically distributed, indicating no potential bias in the results of MR analysis and that the results were reliable and stable.
Considering that gout is characterized by an increase in blood uric acid levels, this study chose blood uric acid levels as an auxiliary exposure factor.Te results of IVW method (OR � 1.20; (95% CI: 1.07-1.34,P � 0.001308087 < 0.05)) and WME method (OR � 1.19; 95% CI: 1.02-1.38,P � 0.026628431 < 0.05) indicate that high blood uric acid levels increase the risk of angina attacks.At the same time, the scatter plot shows that the causal association estimates of IVW method, MR-Egger method, and weighted median method are similar, and the IVW result is accurate, indicating that the MR result is accurate.Te MR-Egger regression method was used to evaluate horizontal pleiotropy, and it was found that there was no horizontal pleiotropy (egger interval � −0.0045, P � 0.631 > 0.05).According to Cochran Q test, IVW (P � 0.2997 > 0.05) and MR-Egger (P � 0.2977 > 0.05) indicate no heterogeneity.Te sensitivity analysis results of the leave-one-out method showed that after sequentially removing each SNP, the IVW analysis results of the remaining SNPs were similar to the analysis results of including all SNPs, and no strongly infuential SNP sites were found, that is, SNPs did not have a nonspecifc impact on the results.On the funnel plot, we can observe Pain Research and Management that the scatter plot of causal correlation efects is basically symmetrically distributed, indicating that there is no potential bias in the MR analysis results, and the results are reliable and stable.Further, we conducted a meta-analysis on the IVW results of the gout (ukb-a-107) and blood uric acid levels (bbj-a-57) (OR � 1.20; 95% CI: 1.07-1.34,P � 0.02), indicating that gout characterized by high blood uric acid levels signifcantly increases the risk of angina.
Previous observational studies have shown that cardiovascular events such as angina pectoris are closely related to the occurrence of gout [3,4], and an increasing number of patients have unstable angina combined with gout [28].A prospective study has suggested that the two may share a similar infammatory process.hs-CRP and IL-6-mediated infammatory response are common pathological processes in both, and IL-6 not only accelerates the formation of  unstable plaques in collaboration with angiotensin II but also participates in the acute phase of gouty attacks [29,30].
In addition to the disease itself, related therapeutic agents, including gout and cardiovascular therapeutic agents, have an interactive efect on both diseases.Gout is a metabolic disease that is closely associated with various diseases, especially cardiovascular disease.Terefore, antiinfammatory therapy may play a role in controlling and stabilizing the clinical course of both diseases.Te antiinfammatory efects of colchicine in cardiovascular disease have received increasing attention in recent years [31].Higher doses of colchicine may have stronger antiinfammatory efects on cardiovascular diseases and better clinical efcacy; however, the role and safety of diferent doses of colchicine in patients with unstable angina combined with acute gout need to be further explored.
Te specifc mechanism through which gout increases angina attacks has not been elucidated by scientifc studies to date.Both diseases, angina and gout, exhibit complex pathogenetic mechanisms that are related to immune and genetic factors and may interact with each other.In addition to traditional cardiovascular risk factors, infammation is an important risk factor for cardiovascular disease.Gout is a common infammatory disease, and gouty attacks are characterized by acute neutrophil-predominant infammation caused by the activation of NLRP3 infammasome [32].Blockade of the NALP3 infammasome was found to prevent the recurrence of cardiovascular events in a randomised clinical trial [33].Terefore, clarifying the causal relationship between angina and gout development and assessing the possibility of promoting the development of both could help in the precise prevention and control of angina combined with gout.In addition, gout is a disease caused by purine metabolism disorders and/or reduced uric acid excretion.Its clinical characteristics include elevated blood uric acid, recurrent episodes of characteristic acute arthritis, formation of gouty stones, chronic gouty stone arthritis, and possible involvement of the kidneys.By adopting a reasonable low purine diet and appropriate medication treatment, lower blood uric acid levels at 360 μmol/L, it is an important goal to eliminate joint swelling and pain, reduce the frequency of gout attacks, and protect internal organs [34,35].Tis study further considered and confrmed that high blood uric acid levels signifcantly increase the risk of angina attacks.Some scholars have shown that uric acid is an important independent marker of coronary artery spasm angina [36].Clinical data analysis of 124 patients diagnosed with stable or unstable angina and chronic complete occlusion by coronary angiography revealed a correlation between high uric acid levels and poor collateral circulation in the coronary arteries [37].Te virtual histology intravascular ultrasound was used to evaluate the noncoronary atherosclerotic lesions of 119 patients with angina pectoris during percutaneous coronary intervention and 8 months after statin treatment; Statin therapy alleviates coronary atherosclerosis and reduces blood uric acid levels [38].Karabag et al. confrmed that serum uric acid levels are associated with SYNTAX score II and long-term mortality in patients with multi vessel lesions and/or unprotected left main trunk lesions receiving percutaneous coronary intervention [39].Yang et al. found a positive correlation between blood uric acid and the Gensini score of coronary artery stenosis in patients with coronary heart disease, which is an independent predictive factor for evaluating the degree of coronary artery stenosis [40].

Conclusion
Tis study used a two-sample MR method to infer the causal relationship between angina pectoris and gout attacks and preliminarily concluded that a positive causal relationship exists between the two.Considering that gout is characterized by an increase in blood uric acid levels, this study also confrmed that high blood uric acid levels increase the risk of angina attacks.Although the specifc mechanisms have not been elucidated, this study enhances the thinking on the risk factors for the onset of these two diseases.Although the specifc mechanism was not elucidated, the fndings enhance the consideration of the risk factors for the development of these two diseases.Patients with gout often experience cardiovascular diseases in combination, and few guidelines have recommended drug treatment programs.We expect that subsequent studies will focus on the group of patients with gout combined with angina pectoris and report on the risk factors for angina pectoris in patients with acute gout, as well as the anti-infammatory and analgesic treatment programs for the two diseases, to reduce the acute attacks of Pain Research and Management angina pectoris in patients with gout and provide a basis for decision-making in terms of clinical drug treatment.In addition, strengthening the early screening for the onset of angina pectoris in patients with gout as well as the timely prevention and treatment of the disease is of signifcance in controlling the prevalence of the disease.However, our research still has limitations.First, our MR analysis found that gout increases the risk of angina, and uric acid, as a mediating factor, is particularly important in the study of the mechanism between gout and angina.Further analysis revealed that blood uric acid increases the risk of angina.However, there is some heterogeneity in the results of metaanalysis, and further confrmation with more datasets and samples should be considered in subsequent studies to reduce heterogeneity.Second, the incidence of gout and angina is higher in males than females, but our data are all from public databases and cannot be analysed for subgroups of specifc factors such as age and gender.Tirdly, all subjects in the GWAS data are of European or East Asian ancestry, and further research is needed to determine whether the results can be extended to other populations.Fourthly, increasing the sample size of GWAS can enhance the intensity of IV.We need larger scale GWAS for in-depth research and support from clinical multicenter epidemiological studies.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Genetic association between gout and angina pectoris; schematic diagram of a bidirectional Mendelian randomization (MR) design.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Forest plot of two-sample MR analysis of the relationship between gout/blood uric acid levels and angina pectoris.

Figure 3 :
Figure 3: Scatter plot of the two-sample MR analysis results of the relationship between gout/blood uric acid levels and angina pectoris.

Figure 5 :Figure 4 :
Figure 5: Te forest map based on the results of the "leave-one-out" test of the relationship between gout/blood uric acid levels and angina pectoris.

Heterogeneity: I 2 =Figure 6 :
Figure6: Forest plot of meta-analysis of IVW results on the relationship between gout/blood uric acid levels and angina pectoris.

Table 1 :
Summary information of genome-wide association study (GWAS) data in Mendelian randomization research.

Table 3
employed to evaluate the impact of weak IVs; and P value signifes the level of association between the SNPs and gout.All genetic tools related to gout and blood uric acid levels had a genome-wide signifcance level (P < 5 ×10e−8; F > 10), indicating that the results were not biased by weak IVs, suggesting the reliability of the present results.
). POS and CHR represent the gene location and chromosomal information, respectively; EAF signifes the frequency of efect alleles; EA/OA represents the allele; β signifes the efect size of gout-related SNPs; SE represents the standard error of the β-value; F-value is a statistical measure SE � 1.424809; P � 0.013545815) showed that gout results in an increased risk of angina pectoris (OR � 33.72; 95% CI � 2.07-550.38).Te results of the WME method showed that gout is signifcantly associated with the development of angina (β � 4.059363; SE � 1.554640; P � 0.009024423; OR � 57.94; 95% CI � 2.75-1219.82).Te results of the MR-Egger, WM, IVW, SM, and WME analysis of blood uric acid levels were shown in the forest plot (Figure2(b)).Te MR-Egger method (β � 0.2638195; Se � 0.10406996; P � 0.016694818), indicating that high blood uric acid levels have a signifcant tendency to cause angina (OR � 1.30; 95% CI: 1.06-1.60).Te IVW method (β � 0.1802265; Se � 0.05607197; P � 0.001308087), high blood uric acid levels can lead to an increased risk of angina (OR � 1.20; 95% CI: 1.07-1.34).Te WME showed a signifcant correlation between high blood uric acid levels and the incidence of angina pectoris (β � 0.1706601; Se � 0.07698065; P � 0.026628431; OR � 1.19; 95% CI: 1.02-1.38).A scatter plot was used to observe the consistency among the results obtained from each assessment method, and the causal association among the estimates from the IVW, MR-Egger, and WME methods was similar, as judged by the slopes of the straight lines.Moreover, the IVW results prevailed, indicating that the MR results were accurate.People method regression was used to verify the presence of pleiotropy in the study.Te relationship between gout and angina pectoris was tested, and the results showed that the value of the Egger intercept was −0.0045, which is close to 0, SE � 0.0091, P � 0.6313, and MRPRESSO Global test P � 0.11, indicating that the MR results do not face interference by the gene pleiotropy efect.Similarly, the test 4Pain Research and Management

Table 2 :
Status of gout-related instrumental variables.

Table 3 :
Status of instrumental variables related to blood uric acid levels.
−0.0055, which is close to 0, SE � 0.0057, P � 0.3477, MRPRESSO Global test P � 0.351, indicating that there is no interference from multiple gene efects in the MR results.value and Q p of IVW and MR-Egger regression were 25.2367 (0.0658) and 24.8393 (0.0521), respectively, and the P value was >0.05, indicating that there was no heterogeneity